R.I.S. – Judith Krug – First Amendment Warrior

Judith Krug, First Amendment Heroine, Dead at 69

Judith Krug, First Amendment Heroine, Dead at 69

Judith Krug headed the American Library Association’s Office of Intellectual Freedom since 1967 and founded the Freedom to Read Foundation. She fought the banning of such titles as “Huckleberry Finn,” “Mein Kampf,” “Little Black Sambo,” “Catcher in the Rye” and sex manuals. In 1982, she founded Banned Books Week — an annual festival that promotes titles that some have attempted to ban.

“My personal proclivities have nothing to do with how I react as a librarian,” Ms. Krug said in an interview with The New York Times in 1972. “Library service in this country should be based on the concept of intellectual freedom, of providing all pertinent information so a reader can make decisions for himself.” (source)

Krug was instrumental in the fight against Section 2257 and the “minors display” ordinances that were fashionable in the 1980’s. Most impressively, she convinced 13 federal judges to unanimously strike down the MacKinnon-Dworkin anti-pornography ordinance.

She invented Banned Books Week. Although the ALA lost some—the Virginia library/computer case and the seven-year battle against 2257, every time you cite a case beginning “ALA” you’re benefitting from her work. ALA v. Virginia basically neutered the rash of “minors’ display” ordinances that the censors came up with in the ’80s and the ALA got 13 federal judges to unanimously strike a “MacKinnon-Dworkin” anti-pornography ordinance, which would have repealed the First Amendment in the area of sexual expression.

We don’t lower the flag to half mast lightly at the Legal Satyricon. But, for Judith Krug, we are honored to do so.

3 Responses to R.I.S. – Judith Krug – First Amendment Warrior

  1. Marty says:

    thanks for bringing this fantastic lady to our attention!

  2. Ahcuah says:

    I too am saddened to hear of her death. Whenever I talked to her on the phone she always seemed very nice.

    However, I’m not sure I would heap as much praise on her as you do. It was her job. Yes, she cared deeply about doing it, and doing it well. But the cases that she and the ALA got involved with were the easy ones. And by “easy” I mean, more-or-less the obvious ones. It’s easy to be against censorship. It’s easy to be against legislators trying to remove books from your shelves. It’s easy to be against internet censorship. It’s easy, because you will have the support of all of your colleagues, and the support of folks like our Satyricon. You will get the admiration of many, and those who matter to you will not question you.

    When it came to less easy ones, they took the easy way out and passed. Anybody can do that. It’s harder, though, to support an issue of the physical access to libraries. It’s harder to support allowing the unconventionally dressed to use libraries, too (particularly when that dress did not hurt the library in the least, and did not disturb other patrons in the least). And on that front, the ALA under Ms. Krug failed.

    In less easy cases, colleagues might question your support. Colleagues may want you to uphold their authority to order patrons around. And it is all so easy to take the easy way out. That’s the area in which, if Ms. Krug had gotten more involved, I would offer more praise.

  3. legalboxerbriefs says:

    It’s always unfortunate to see someone like this pass away.

    On another note, Catcher in the Rye is approximately a billion times overrated.