Xbiz reports that the government’s case, failing to meet its burden of proof on any of the counts against Stagliano, has been dismissed.
The trial, pending before Judge Richard Leon in the United States District Court for the District of Columbia, was dismissed on the defense team’s Rule 29 motion at the end of the government’s case. And what a team it was: H. Louis Sirkin, lead counsel for John Stagliano Inc. and Paul Cambria Jr., lead counsel for Stagliano. A solo practitioner, Allan Gelbard, represented Evil Angel Productions. Davis Wright Tremaine partner Robert Corn-Revere served as local counsel. (source.)
The proceedings came to a jarring halt when the government’s star witness, an FBI agent, impeached his own credibility while calling the judge’s and prosecutor’s into question. From that point onward, the government could not surmount the burden of proof it bore under the constitution.
Beginning in 2008, the government’s case against Stagliano accused him of enough crimes to put him in prison for more than 30 years. Despite running Evil Angel for two decades, the case against Stagliano rested upon mere minutes of footage, with the remainder of his natural life potentially in jeopardy.
UPDATE: Additional coverage available at AVN, courtesy of Mark Kernes.
[…] BREAKING: JUDGE DISMISSES STAGLIANO OBSCENITY CASE Despite running Evil Angel for two decades, the case against Stagliano rested upon mere minutes of footage, with the remainder of his natural life potentially in jeopardy.Murderers get lighter sentences, government priorities for you. […]
[…] immediately reached for comment Friday evening.I wonder if she would be reachable if she had won.BREAKING: JUDGE DISMISSES STAGLIANO OBSCENITY CASE Despite running Evil Angel for two decades, the case against Stagliano rested upon mere minutes of […]
I wrote about the case as well at avn.com. Here’s a link to the last article: http://business.avn.com/articles/Feds-Lose-Stagliano-Obscenity-Case-First-in-Over-30-Years-403911.html
[…] most of the successful people in the industry faced criminal charges for obscenity at some point, even recently, and others still […]
[…] against the adult industry. (The last obscenity prosecution that actually made it to trial failed spectacularly.) Why an appointed official such as Holder should care about public pressure is unclear, and this […]
[…] to the lifetime oeuvre of, for example, John “Buttman” Stagliano – someone who risked a lengthy prison term to follow his principles – anal sex is not merely a reality for many men, but expected. Sure, Stagliano got wealthy […]