Bastille Day

In celebration of Bastille Day, today’s entry is my annual expression of gratitude to La République Française et les citoyens français (the French Republic and the French Citizens).

It is all too popular of an American sport and political diversioin, to mock, insult, and scapegoat the French. They frequently oppose U.S. foreign policy, have a reputation for rudeness, and we do often hate that which we do not understand. I will agree that the Gallic mentality is sometimes unintelligible to me, and that France and the French are not without their current and historical flaws. Nevertheless, Anti-gallic propaganda has unfortunately convinced many Americans to forget the tremendous debt we owe to our French brothers and sisters.

Gandhi said “be the change you want to see in the world.” I want to see a world where Americans show proper respect to our “true Mother Country.”


Without the French, there would be no “United States of America”

We should never forget that but for the Marquis de Lafayette, the American Revolution would likely have failed. (It is no surprise that he is one of only five people in history to be granted “honorary citizenship” by the United States. Lafayette is a perfect symbol for the fact that the French were essentially the nurses to the infant United States. Nevertheless, French support for our struggle against King George took the form of money, men, munitions, and diplomacy. French blood was the mother’s milk of the Revolution.

But for the French, the “Star Spangled Banner” would either never have been written, and depending on where in the United States you currently live, you would be a citizen of the United Kingdom, France itself, Spain, Russia, Mexico, or perhaps an unconceivable independent nation. The fact is, but for the French, there would be no America. Merci beaucoup mes amis.

Without the French, the “dream” of America would not exist.

The French have not only given us our independence, but gave us the very philosophy upon which we founded this great nation – the spirit of the enlightenment. Admittedly, this was not a purely French phenomenon. Nevertheless, what would the enlightenment have been without Montesquieu who bestowed the theory of separation of powers upon us? Republican, Democrat, Libertarian, or otherwise, who (besides George Bush, Karl Rove, and Dick Cheney) is not grateful for this gallic gift?

François-Marie Arouet, more commonly known as Voltaire, was an early defender of civil liberties, including freedom of religion and the right to a fair trial. Who wouldn’t be? Well, in Voltaire’s day there were strong censorship laws in France, and harsh penalties for those with the courage or stupidity to defy them.

Jean-Jacques Rousseau Political philosopher wrote the “Social Contract,” which serves as the theoretical foundation of our modern notions of a democratic government.

I could go on, but I believe my point is made. When you think of the theoretical underpinnings of the constitution, you have no business doing so without whispering to yourself, “merci beaucoup encore.”

Bastille Day

The Bastille was a notorious prison where the French Monarchy held political prisoners and those whose writing challenged their power and authority. As a factual matter, on July 14, 1789 at the time of the storming of the Bastille, there were only seven prisoners, none of whom were of any political significance, and the siege had little practical effect upon the French Revolution. Nevertheless, the storming was a rallying point for the French Revolution and a destruction of a key symbol of the French monarchy’s absolutism. What could be more “American” than the people rising up to destroy a prison where the authorities held political prisoners, jailed for their writing on matters of political importance?

Perhaps there are those who believe that we have paid our debt to France by “bailing them out of two world wars.” I say otherwise. I anticipate that the day will come that I will have spent more of my life caring for my parents than they spent caring for me. (At least I hope so). Nevertheless, without my parents, I would neither have my existence nor my personality. As I can never repay that debt in full, I believe that our debt to France will never reach zero. Therefore, today, on their national holiday, I extend my gratitude and love for France and the French — flaws and all.

Vive la France!

Le Marquis de Lafayette

10 Responses to Bastille Day

  1. evrenseven says:

    I wonder if there’s a Glenn Beck analog in France who twists Bastille Day into some sort of anti tax/ muslim/ whatever thing. JUST AS THE ARISTOCRACY KEPT PRISONERS IN THE BASTILLE, SARKOZY KEEPS OUR TAX DOLLARS IN A MODERN DAY BASTILLE! LET’S STORM IT!

  2. ajb says:

    Couldn’t agree more.

  3. Jonathan C. Hansen says:

    Hey – thanks for a little education that I must have missed in school. Hadn’t really thought about it that way before, even though the motivation at the time may have been more a result of France wanting to counter the British than assist in our own independence, there’s no doubt that they established many of the principles incorporated in the Constitution. Given that the Constitution also adopted the ideas behind the Magna Carta, I really don’t hold much stock in nationalism today against either country, or that one or the other “gave rise” to our system. That was a long time ago, and the world situation is almost unrecognizably different. I also admit that I don’t understand current animosity towards the French. On some issues, I admire their openess and practicality, for example, with regards to sexuality and its discussion – in contrast to a reflexive prudity (prudishness?) here in the US. Is that one aspect perceived of as “rude” by some here?

  4. Sean F. says:

    Well, one could argue that the debt of blood that we owe France was to Imperial France. The very France that was ousted by the revolution that Bastille Day celebrates.

  5. jfischer1975 says:

    …and yet their contemporary idea of “freedom” includes fining people for wearing veils.

  6. [...] Bastille Day « The Legal Satyricon [...]

  7. CJC says:

    A little much. There were just as many incredible Enlightenment thinkers in Scotland and England and Germany (and the colonies!) that we took ideas from. The fact is, the Americans were the first to cowboy up and put their necks on the line for the principles they espoused. The French were a little slow to do the same.

    How many revolutuions did the French have between 1789 and 1850? How many were successful?

    If you’re going to thank the French for something, I think you should at least thank little Napoleon for selling us the Louisiana territory at a discount – since it really belonged to Spain at the time!

  8. [...] Bastille Day « The Legal Satyricon&#10&#77&#111nday Morning LitLinks | Author Scoop [...]

  9. Thilo says:

    We saved their bacon in two world wars. We are either even or they owe us, not the other way around. As far as I’m concerned, we can bust on the French as much as we want.

    One more thing, we did better than you did in the World Cup, France, so there…

    :-)

    PS: The foregoing posting should not be taken too seriously (unless you are French)

    • Sean F. says:

      We did very little in WWI. The war was a stalemate when we got there and nobody actually won the bloody thing.

      Soviet Russia would have been enought to stop the nazi war machine in WWII, but if we weren’t there then most, if not all, of Europe would have been under soviet control. In essence, our participation in WWII set the world up for the Cold War and we used France as a buffer state between us and the USSR.

      Whether that’s a good or bad thing is a matter of opinion, but we hardly saved their bacon in either World War.

      We were responsible for much of post-war Europe’s economic recovery though.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 465 other followers