I got an iPhone on December 2, and all I can say is that I’m glad that AT&T has a 30 day return policy. My biggest complaints to date:
- No “cut and paste” — still — and people have been complaining about that since the first iPhone came out. What good is it to have web access and email, but no cut and paste?
- The “virtual keyboard” is nifty, but completely impractical and makes my hand feel like it has turned into a claw after using it for more than 15 minutes.
- I’m not sure what would last longer, an erection in the presence of Katherine Harris or the iPhone’s battery.
- And even though the battery life sucks, you can’t just carry a spare battery with you, as the battery is not user-replaceable.
- The camera utterly sucks. Don’t get me wrong, I realize that a phone isn’t a camera, and my last blackberry didn’t even have a camera (and I bought it for that reason). But, if you’re going to bother to put a camera in a media device, don’t make it suck ass.
- Speaking of pictures, you can attach ONE picture to each email. Sending an email on this thing is a big enough pain in the ass. Doing it repetitively to send additional files is just painful.
- No MMS. If someone sends me a picture message, I’ve got to log on to the internet and enter in a picture ID and a password, both of which are generated by the system, both of which are incredibly hard to remember. If I could CUT AND PASTE, it might be okay, but this way I either have to grow a photographic memory or whip out a pencil to write down the codes.
- You can’t forward a text message
- Apple touts it as having the “real internet” on it. I have news for Apple, the real internet uses FLASH — a lot. If I can’t see websites that use Flash, I can’t view exotic websites like the BOSTON GLOBE
- Every goddamn time I want to charge the phone by plugging it into my USB jack, stupid iTunes launches.
- Speaking of iTunes, that is the only way you can get files on or off the iPhone. Even my $19 MP3 player can work as an external hard drive. Apple disabled that function on the iPhone. (Yes, there are third-party workarounds, but why make something so simple like “drag and drop files” into a pain in the ass?
- It has a GPS, but no turn-by-turn directions like my $50 Garmin that runs on AA batteries. So, if you’re driving, you HAVE to look at the phone’s screen to navigate. It might be great if you’re walking around Noe Valley, but most of us use GPS in the damn car.
- No tethering to your laptop.
- No removable storage. It has a slot for a SIM card, but Apple figured we wouldn’t want removable storage.
- The iPhone is a Piece of Shit, and So is Your Face (Okay, I didn’t make that one up)
- Applications like mail and the browser crash CONSTANTLY. Way to give us the Windows Vista experience, Apple!
I really really tried to like this thing. I kept making excuses for it. Despite my lengthy list of reasons to hate it, I figured I might just keep it. My cell phones rarely last a year anyhow, and I did like the fact that it automatically synchronized contacts and calendar entries with my Macintosh. Even better, it would auto-synch with my iPod touch that I leave at home.
But, if I’m on the fence about a product, the most sure-fire way to piss me off and have me running for the return aisle is to let me find out that Apple is censoring content from the app store based on automatic scans for “dirty words.” If an e-book has the word “fuck” in it, you can’t read it on your iPhone. To be honest, I don’t think I would ever read a book on an iPhone anyway, and I’m as big a Mac cheerleader/fanboy as you’ll find, but fuck Cupertino if it thinks that I’m going to support it on a product that has an electronic Anthony Comstock inside it.
My next text message will be sent from a new Blackberry Bold.
By RSS Feed

December 26, 2008 at 10:15 am |
A lot of stuff on that list I’ve gotten used to not having, such as the MMS or ability to forward text messages. The battery life has gotten much better and I can get a day’s worth of heavy use out of it.
#10, 11 and 16 are not true, in my experience at least. I’ve always used Win Explorer to mass delete files off my iPhone. I haven’t had the browser or mail crash even once and in fact, when I plug it in via USB, iTunes NEVER launches.
The keyboard takes some getting used to, but once you have it down, it works really well and the suggestions are usually spot on.
Speaking of user-friendly, what is up with the size of the text in the comment box here? I can barely see what I’m typing. the rest of the page is okay, but this is almost unreadable.
December 26, 2008 at 10:21 am |
I agree that my comments font is too small. I don’t know how to fix it, but I’ll see what I can do.
December 26, 2008 at 10:28 am |
And while you may be able to mass delete files from your iPhone, can you drag and drop a PDF, a PowerPoint presentation, a picture, or a document *on to* your iPhone? Maybe the iTunes thing is just a setting, and I’m a nimrod for not being able to find it to change it, but the crash? Mine crashes constantly.
I can see how the keyboard can work for some people, but the suggestions are right about 70% of the time for me. It is so horrible that it is now costing me billing. I used to just shoot quick emails to my assistant when I had billing events outside the office so that time wouldn’t be lost. Now, with the iPhone, I just rely on my memory because using this thing is such a pain in the ass.
And, of course, this is probably not an issue that most people have, but if you try typing on the iPhone in shorthand or in another language (I do a lot of communication in Italian), you can just forget about it.
December 26, 2008 at 10:33 am |
That’s true, but it’s not a true business phone like the BB. It’s a consumer phone that they’re trying to mold into the business variety. It will fall short. I love it for everything I do – checking e-mail, sending quick one-liners, texting, surfing the web, watching videos on youtube and playing games. the camera is definitely a bit wanting, but hey…
It’s a true Apple product – looks good, does most things well, but is overhyped and overpriced.
December 26, 2008 at 10:41 am |
Agreed… but, I actually don’t think it is overpriced. It was worth $199 just for the iPod inside it. (but, I already own an iPod touch, which I like just fine).
The Apple DNA problem it has is Cupertino’s desire to keep training wheels on all their products. For their computers, I’m willing to accept the tradeoff (my macintosh hasn’t crashed or locked up since the day I got it), but for my mobile device, I need reliability and practical usefulness.
December 26, 2008 at 4:27 pm |
Interesting perspective. I’m quite the opposite. I had a blackberry pearl and absolutely hated it. However, I adore my iPhone and find it much easier to use. In fact it is what I am I am using right now.
December 27, 2008 at 12:23 am |
I’ve used blackberries for about 8 years. I’ve only used a combo blackberry-phone for about two. I don’t use my phone as a phone very often, but I do a lot of emailing.
I switched to the iphone early this month — an early Christmas present. Yes, for email it is inferior to the blackberry. The battery life is also problematical. But overall, I’m sold. I like having all of my toys in one small gadget. Plus, I just downloaded Puzzle Quest during a particularly boring conference call. You can’t beat that.
December 31, 2008 at 1:41 pm |
If you have to do a zillion e-mails every day the BB is still tops, but the BB stinks for everything else. The iPhone is a perfect phone for the person that e-mails, sms’s, and phones less than a dozen times a day and wants to be able to access the web easily and listen to tunes on the commute. Also, we just went on a long road trip and the iPhone was a perfect companion for that. Audiobooks to listen to, GPS to check the map, the web to look for hotel reservations — the BB can’t compete with that — web on the BB is awful.
And, really, how can you get used to any new keyboard interface in a few days? I hated the iPhone keyboard when I first got it 6 weeks ago and also felt I’d made a mistake — now I am using it all the time and have no problems. When the BB came out people said it’s keyboard was “unusable” too.
December 31, 2008 at 1:53 pm |
I think you’re right. Unfortunately, I e-mail and SMS about a hundred times a day.
And I gave the iPhone 28 days (two days before I couldn’t return it). I really really really tried to like it. I actually could have possibly tolerated the keyboard, but the lack of cut-and paste was completely intolerable — as was the fact that every damn thing on the iPhone takes five or six actions. On the BB, one handed on the trackball, one click, and you’ve got your messages. Don’t get me started on the GPS for the iPhone. Yuck. No turn by turn?
January 2, 2009 at 1:01 pm |
[...] HARDARE: The iPhone Sucks – Smart owner lists 16 problems he discovered in 26 days before returning … Wow, people pay for this shit? [...]
February 21, 2009 at 2:31 pm |
[...] Personally, I agree with the EFF, but I found a better alternative to jailbreaking my iPhone. I returned the piece of crap and got a [...]
March 17, 2009 at 4:40 pm |
Good news: http://apple20.blogs.fortune.cnn.com/2009/03/17/major-iphone-upgrade-coming-this-summer/
March 31, 2009 at 5:34 pm |
you suck!